Introduction:
For what feels like an eternity now, I’ve wanted desperately to write about the latest A24 feature, ‘Past Lives’, and its subtle brilliances in terms of cinematic storytelling, cinematography, directing, etc.
But, every time I started to write this article, I felt this underlying dread creep within my soul. A solemn dread reminding me that in order to fully analyze and communicate why I believe this film is so impactful. I would first have to re-watch ‘Past Lives’.

And no, it’s not because I found the film boring or dull or bland. The reason why I feared rewatching ‘Past Lives’ was due to the fact that I believe the film is without a doubt, the most tragic and heartbreaking piece of cinema I’ve ever witnessed. The simple concepts of regret, love, bitter-sweet nostalgia, moving on and In-Yun that seem to permeate throughout Celine Song’s directorial debut. Seamlessly blending together into a romantic drama that feels both heart-wrenching to watch, yet, unabashedly easy to relate to.
Celine Song’s first feature film is one that sits with you long after you leave the cinema. It is a true masterclass of storytelling that, unfortunately, has flown under the radar for a lot of cinema-goers, who had been spoiled by the stacked slate of films released in 2023.

And, with ‘Past Lives’ only grossing $14.6 million at the Global Box Office against its $12 million budget, it’s clear that the film unfortunately did not reach the mass audience it deserved to.
However, by analyzing and dissecting Celine Song’s tragic triumph through its story, its visuals and, its themes. I wish to unpack and uncover what elements makes ‘Past Lives’ stand out when compared to other films that released alongside the latest A24 masterpiece.
This is what makes ‘Past Lives’ a Heart Breaking Tale of…What If?
1. The Pain That Comes from…What If?
Written and directed by Celine Song herself. The story of ‘Past Lives’ serves as an almost auto-biographical rendition of Celine Song’s life. Drawing upon her own experiences as a South Korean who immigrated to Canada, Celine Song uses her own life to create the storyline and characters that ‘Past Lives’ revolve around.

The story of ‘Past Lives’ shows the fractured relationship of two South Koreans, Na Young, (portrayed by actress Greta Lee) and Hae Sung, (portrayed by actor Teo Yoo).
‘Past Lives’ narrative deals with how sometimes a love between two people is never meant to be, and the pains that come with moving on in life…even if you’re not ready to.


Editorial Note:
I will be summarizing the plot of Past Lives in the following paragraphs. If you wish to experience the film yourself, (which I highly recommend) or wish to simply read the analytical elements. Then please skip the following paragraphs.
We, the audience, watch as the seeds of Na Young and Hae Sung’s relationship are sown early together from a young age, with the two living together as friends in Seoul, South Korea. However, when Na Young is forced to suddenly immigrate to Canada and subsequently change her name to Nora Moon, the two close friends lose contact with one another for several years.
It isn’t until twelve years later when Na Young and Hae Sung would reconnect over Skype. With Na Young (now Nora Moon), having immigrated a second time to New York City, from Canada.
We watch as Hae Sung and Nora begin to cling to each other as the two rekindle their lost relationship, with Nora even wanting to return to South Korea to see Hae Sung in person again.


However, Nora decides not to go through with her plan to visit Hae Sung in Korea and ultimately, focus on her own goals which require her to stay in New York City. Nora decides not to use her past as a crutch, but instead, to attack her future with no baring on the life she used to live. Nora also makes the difficult decision to cut ties with Hae Sung for a second time. A selfless act to hopefully allow both Hae Sung and herself to move on with their lives separately.
Following another twelve-year time jump. We see how Nora has grown from her last interaction with Hae Sung. She has continued with her goal of making a name for herself in New York, she is an up-incoming play writer living in Queens with her husband, Arthur. An author who Nora met during a artist in residents excursion.
Arthur and Nora live happily together in New York City. However, when Hae Sung is invited by Nora to see her again in America, the now mature Hae Sung will travel from Korea to America to finally reunite with Nora in person after spending two decades apart.
Now, Nora, Hae Sung and Arthur will discuss the needs, wants and desires that each central character of Past Live’s yearns for.

Past Lives carries itself with a level of maturity and restraint that isn’t typically seen in a lot of directorial debuts. Each character within the story expresses emotions and reactions that feel genuinely authentic within the narrative.
Considering that many may find themselves relating to the struggles of either Nora, Hae Sung or Arthur, the film serves not to dramatize or exaggerate the natural tension that comes with ‘Past Lives’ narrative.

Celine Song isn’t afraid to both build up and break down the wants, needs and desires of her main characters. This willingness by the director to have her protagonists simply just discuss what could’ve been reflects the level of maturity ‘Past Lives’ narrative has when it comes with dealing with inner-personal relationships.
2. Nostalgia Through The Lens.
In order for ‘Past Lives’ to communicate its themes of nostalgia, growing up, and letting go through the visual storytelling medium. ‘Past Lives’ Director of Photography, Shabier Kirchner, employed a range of mise en scene elements that complement the films cinematography in order to have ‘Past Lives’ feel uniquely timeless.
In order to achieve this timeless feeling and effect, DOP Shabir Kirchner’s decided to film ‘Past Lives’ with Kodak 35mm film stock. (Film stock similar to everyday disposable cameras available to the public).
Shabir used Kodak 35MM Film Stock as to imbue its audience with a sense of nostalgia. The certain feeling one may get after looking at a nostalgic photo captured on a disposable camera. The film’s lack of camera movement mirrors the idea of making the film feel like a nostalgic photograph.

“My lens choices really came from conversations that Celine and I had about camera movement, or the considerable lack of movement, as many scenes play out with a static camera or imperceptible moves.”
Shabir Kirchner
The idea of having ‘Past Lives’ feel like a moving polaroid memory ties perfectly into the film’s many themes, chief among them being nostalgia and the bittersweet questions of…what-if? As if the audience was watching the film through their own bittersweet nostalgia or memories.

In each frame that Nora and Hae Sung share within the film, the two main characters are always divided/separated from each other, even in the films many tight close-ups. This physical divide symbolically represents Nora and Hae Sung’s inability to be together due to external factors in their lives.
Each shot of Nora and Hae Sung together on screen feels worryingly intimate, as if at any sudden moment, the two may give in to their long dormant feelings for each other. However, thankfully the film’s restraint puts those anxious thoughts to rest. Instead, ‘Past Lives’ visually showcases the divide between our main trio through both character blocking and framing.
In addition to this, the colour work in Past Lives allows the film to communicate its themes of bittersweet nostalgia to its audience on a subconscious level. While on initial viewing, it would seem that very little colour work was implemented on the Kodak 35MM footage, with the sizeable concrete jungles that are both New York City and Seoul constantly swallowing the film’s colour palate in harsh concrete greys and blacks.
However, subtle colour hints of pink’s and orange’s ,(colours often synonymous with the feeling of nostalgia), begin to leak through the concrete grey skyscrapers of Seoul and New York City. The literal rose-tinted colors of the film serve to bring warmth and nostalgia to the frame, further pushing the subconscious narrative that both Shabir Kirchner and Celine Song wish to impart to ‘Past Lives’ audience, making the film feel like a moving polaroid photo, trapped in a simpler, more nostalgic, easier time.






3. In-Yun
There is a certain Korean phrase that permeates deeply throughout Past Lives’ narrative, In-Yun.
As described in Catrina Prager’s article on the topic;
In-Yun is the belief that the interactions between two people in this life are owed to interactions (or near-interactions) in their past lives. The concept suggests that some encounters are not, as we might at first assume, accidental, but rather a cosmic tug on our sleeve. The Universe saying here, this human’s important in your journey.
Catrina Prager – Medium
We the audience, see how Celine Song intertwines this ancient Korean concept with Hae Sung and Na Young’s relationship and character journey’s throughout ‘Past Lives’.
At the beginning of the film, it’s heavily implied by Celine Song that Na Young and Hae Sung are destined to be together in cinematic language, (hence the close up shots and long, quiet pauses between our two main characters whenever they interact).


However, even with the two splitting apart from each other and starting new lives separately in other countries. Both Hae Sung and Nora use the memories of their young connection to keep themselves grounded in reality.
So, when Hae Sung finally gets to meet with Na Young (now Nora Strong) in New York City, far away from Korea and two decades after they first parted ways. Both Nora and Hae Sung are both once again confronted with In-Yun, now manifested as the reconnected relationship between the two main characters.
While the two had physically grown apart, Hae Sung and Nora’s spiritual connection with each other continues to bring the two main characters together, meeting again and again. Yet, the two constantly try moving on from their young and brash relationship, with the two focusing on things that have become more important then a lost relationship.
Yet, it’s Hae Sung and Na Young’s past life together in Seoul that compels and binds the two almost soulmates to reconnect and understand what could’ve been if certain things had changed in their lives.
“If you had never left Seoul…would I still have looked for you? Would we have dated? Broken Up? Gotten Married? Would we have had kids together?”
Hae Sung to Nora during their conversation together.

From the fallout of Na Young and Hae Sung’s undeveloped relationship comes the emotional baggage and accompanying pain of what could of been, commonly associated with grief or loss.
The death of a relationship that should’ve been in this life, but was instead destined for another.
In-Yun in the context of Past Lives refers to the nature of Hae Sung and Na Young’s relationship. The fact the two could have been soul mates in this lifetime, yet, In-Yun dictates that they could instead be together in the next life, or the life after that. But not this one.
Conclusion:
Celine Song’s directorial debut is a heart-breaking masterclass of cinema that blends complex themes with beautiful cinematography, nostalgic colors and engaging dialogue.
The manner in which Past Lives conveys it’s themes of In-Yun, bittersweet nostalgia and growing up is handled with a level of maturity and subtly that is severely lacking in modern cinema in general, let alone a directorial debut.
Furthermore, by pairing Celine Song’s storytelling ability with Shabir Kirchner’s crafty, nostalgic cinematography that makes ‘Past Lives’ feel more akin to a moving polaroid picture. It’s no surprise that A24’s latest masterpiece has received Oscar nominations for both Best Picture and Best Original Screenplay.
Past Lives is a film that sits with audiences long after they exit the theatre, its inability to pull any emotional punches and ability to connect / relate to everyone’s desire for love on a emotional level is why, Past Lives is a heart-breaking tale of…what if?

Written, Curated and Edited by Michael Qualischefski.

















































